The Federal Court of Canada has recently sent a strong message to applicants seeking permanent residency, warning them that they must follow the court’s orders strictly. The case involves Iranian nationals who applied for Canadian permanent residency under the self-employed class and faced refusals from the visa office in Warsaw, Poland.
Background of the Case
This case started because many Iranian applicants were denied permanent residency by the Canadian visa office in Warsaw, Poland. These applicants filed about 100 cases challenging these refusals. The cases were grouped together as one large case in 2023.
- What is Group Litigation?
Group litigation means that multiple related legal cases are combined into one to be handled together in court. This makes it easier for the court to handle similar cases at once.
Court’s Orders and the Applicants’ Disregard
In August 2023, the Federal Court set clear rules for these cases. The court ordered the applicants to stick to certain issues and not introduce any new arguments or evidence. The applicants were given time extensions to submit their records, but some still made mistakes in meeting deadlines.
- What Went Wrong?
The applicants missed the initial deadline for submitting their records, and when they finally did submit them, they included new evidence and arguments that weren’t allowed according to the court’s rules.
The court decided that the applicants were trying to sidestep the orders and bring up new issues beyond what was agreed on. The court was not happy with this, saying that it would not tolerate further disobedience of its orders.
Court’s Decision on the Applicants’ Requests
The applicants wanted the court to allow them to submit more evidence and change the focus of the case. They also wanted to challenge decisions affecting all similar cases since 2018.
- What Did the Court Decide?
The court denied these requests, stating that allowing the changes would make the case unmanageable and delay things further. The court also warned that the size of the group involved in the litigation would not protect them from negative consequences.
What Happens Next?
The court gave an extension for submitting the applicants’ records, but it made it clear that the records should only focus on the issues originally outlined in 2023. The applicants were warned not to try expanding the case any further.
The court also explained that, because of delays, the hearings might not even begin until 2027, even though the case started nearly 30 months ago.
Key Takeaways
- The Federal Court is serious about applicants following its orders.
- Applicants trying to bypass these rules or expand the case beyond the court’s instructions face consequences.
- The court extended the deadline for applicants but warned them that further disobedience would not be tolerated.
Credit: CANADIAN LAWYER
Q1: What does it mean when the court says applicants “disobey orders”?
A1: When the court gives specific instructions, such as deadlines or issues to focus on, applicants must follow those rules. If they don’t, they are “disobeying orders,” which can negatively impact their case.
Q2: Why did the court refuse to allow more evidence in the case?
A2: The court felt that introducing more evidence would make the case harder to manage and cause unnecessary delays. It wanted the applicants to stick to the issues already agreed upon.
Q3: How does this case affect people applying for permanent residency in Canada?
A3: This case shows that it’s important to follow all legal instructions when challenging visa decisions. If applicants don’t follow the rules, it could delay their cases and make things more complicated.
Q4: What happens if applicants don’t follow court orders again?
A4: The court has warned that any further disobedience could lead to negative consequences. This could mean the case is dismissed or delayed even longer.
Q5: What should applicants do to avoid issues with their immigration applications?
A5: Applicants should carefully follow all instructions from the court and immigration authorities. Missing deadlines or introducing new arguments without permission can harm their chances of success.
This decision serves as a reminder that following legal procedures is crucial for anyone seeking to challenge a visa refusal or any immigration decision. If you’re considering applying for permanent residency in Canada, it’s important to stay organized, meet deadlines, and follow all instructions carefully to avoid delays and complications.
Would you like a consultation to explore your Canadian work options? Contact Ask Kubeir today!
📌 If you believe your VISA application should be showcased in the most favorable light when submitting to immigration, feel free to book our services.
📌 To book an appointment with Kubeir – Licensed Canadian Immigration Consultant, click the “Book Appointment”
📲 You may also reach us at this number for all immigration-related services:
- (+𝟭) 𝟰𝟯𝟳-𝟳𝟳𝟳-𝟯𝟳𝟳𝟳 (Canada)
- +971 45 26 4646 (Dubai)
Disclaimer: This is for informational purposes only and not legal advice. Always consult experts like us or the official IRCC website for up-to-date details.